He tries to fight these feelings, but they only continue to grow stronger upon their arrival to the movie theater. While there, Tyler finds himself feeling attracted to Gary. The two then go to the arcade to kill time.
Gary, who had always had a crush on Mariah, happily agrees. Gary then arrives to pick him up and, in an attempt to avoid running into the real Mariah, Tyler tricks Gary into letting him come. Tyler accepts, but while trying to find enough money for his ticket, he finds himself becoming trapped in his sister, Mariah's, closet and being transformed into her shortly thereafter. Gary agrees, on the condition Tyler buys his own ticket. Tyler, out of boredom, invites his best friend, Gary, to see a movie. After they're magically turned into each other, however, will they accept their new forms or will they want to change back?
What would it be like having your gender switched with your twin prior to your births? This is the case for Tyler and Mariah, who have been unknowingly living as the wrong sex for their entire lives.